Bay Shore, New York is a captivating waterfront town that holds a unique charm and character. Situated on the South Shore of Long Island, it serves as a gateway to Fire Island, making it a popular stopover for travelers en route to their summer escapes. However, Bay Shore itself is a destination worth exploring with its vibrant restaurant scene, intriguing history, and natural beauty. So, if you find yourself with a couple of spare hours before or after your Fire Island ferry, here are some things you can do in Bay Shore to make the most of your time.
Begin your adventure by strolling down Bay Shore’s main street, where you can indulge in some leisurely window shopping. Stop by Nalu Dry Goods to browse through their selection of surf gear and beachy apparel that compliments Bay Shore’s vibes. If you’re a fan of comics and collectibles, Lost Planet is a must-visit. And for those seeking a great house warming gift, Willy Nilly has it all.
After working up an appetite, treat yourself to a delicious snack or drink. If it’s the morning or early afternoon, head over to Bay Shore Bean for a cup of freshly brewed coffee and a buttery croissant. Alternatively, if you’re in the mood for artisanal cocktails and locally sourced oysters, Salt and Barrel is the place to be. And if you’re craving a sweet and refreshing treat, don’t miss Ralph’s, where you can savor the delightful flavors of their Italian ice.
Once you’ve explored Main Street, take some time to delve into Bay Shore’s rich history and close-knit community. Embark on the Rotary Club of Bay Shore’s historical walk, starting at the Bay Shore Historical Society’s Gibson-Mack-Holt House located on 22 Maple Ave. Here, you can take a photo of the map outside the house and follow the designated route, immersing yourself in the town’s fascinating past.
These activities can easily be enjoyed within a two-hour timeframe, allowing you to make the most of your visit to Bay Shore.
