A sampling of South Shore Long Island top-sellers at the end of last year. What will 2025 bring?
BRIGHTWATERS: 311 Woodland Drive, 11718
DATE SOLD: December 16, 2024
PRICE: $1,200,000
SOLD BY: Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty
DETAILS: Overlooking a wooded grove on the east side of Southward Ho Country Club, this immaculate 1932 home is a quintessential Brightwaters Tudor. The home features a parlor with a wood-burning stove, custom woodworking, and parquet floors situated on a third of an acre. Classic styling mixes with modern convenience: Built-in stereo speakers are featured in the living room entertainment area, and updated soapstone countertops surround an eat-in kitchen. Landscaping in the front yard was recently planted, and a new blacktop driveway was installed just before the property was listed. Located within the Incorporated village of Brightwaters, the home includes amenities including village garbage collection, security services, and access to the Islip Town marina, Walker Beach, and Gilbert and Wohseepee parks.
WEST ISLIP: 10 Duck Lane, 11795
DATE SOLD: December 17, 2024
PRICE: $1,104,100
SOLD BY: Century 21 Crowne Homes
DETAILS: Nestled in community of boat slips and canals between Good Samaritan Hospital, St. John the Baptist Diocesan High School, and the Robert Moses Causeway, this updated and expanded 1964 colonial is located in the prestigious the Cedar Point Estates community. West Islip Beach is a short walk down the block. Its parklike grounds feature an in-ground pool and hot tub. Located in the West Islip School District, this 5-bedroom, 3-bath home includes a newly updated kitchen with quartz countertops and abundant cabinet space.
WEST ISLIP: 244 Fire Island Avenue, 11702
DATE SOLD: November 26, 2024
PRICE: $1,250,000
SOLD BY: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
DETAILS: The buyers of this beautiful brick home will enjoy the best of both worlds. The 2,500-square-foot colonial is situated on a quiet one-third-acre corner lot that’s only a few blocks away from bustling downtown Babylon and its plethora of dining and shopping options. The double-door entry leads into a large foyer with a winding staircase. The first floor features a formal dining room and living room, both with crown moldings and hardwood floors. The kitchen features granite countertops and stainless-steel appliances, and a central vacuum system makes cleaning easy. Boat slips and a resident-only park with pool is located down the block.
FIRE ISLAND PINES: 277 Bay Walk, 11782
DATE SOLD: November 8, 2024
PRICE: $1,465,000
SOLD BY: D. Katen Fire Island Properties
DETAILS: Centrally located in the heart of Fire Island Pines, this three-bedroom updated 1960 cottage boasts three full ensuite bathrooms and one half-bath for guests. The home’s contemporary design, with walls of glass, soaring ceilings, and an open floor plan, makes it feel like new construction. Its gorgeous outdoor living space features a heated pool and large deck with plenty of seating. The home is lifted to current standards, and is air-conditioned and winterized for year-round living. The lot features lush vegetation and feels secluded, yet is only a few blocks from the Pines’ business district.
BROOKHAVEN: 280 Beaver Dam Road, 11702
DATE SOLD: November 26, 2024
PRICE: $1,200,000
SOLD BY: Eileen A. Green Realty Realty
DETAILS: Blending perfectly with older historic homes in the area, this 1993 colonial features four bedrooms and plenty of space. Originally professional office space, a sound-proof area attached to the home includes a waiting room and powder room plumbed for a shower that could be renovated into a primary or nanny suite. Outside, a large two-story deck overlooks the backyard on this oversized 1.3-acre lot – perfect for entertaining. The basement is ready to be finished, complete with eight-foot ceilings. For those who enjoy nature, the Wertheim Wildlife Refuge and Southaven Park are both minutes away.
WEST GILGO BEACH: 43 Ocean Walk, 11702
DATE SOLD: December 3, 2024
PRICE: $1,150,000
SOLD BY: Signature Premier Properties
DETAILS: Completely renovated in 2018, this four-bedroom beach house is one of 80 homes in a private gated community located adjacent to Tobay Beach. Accessible via Ocean Parkway, the neighborhood features its own private beach, docks, tennis and pickleball courts, and a non-denominational house of worship. This home boasts a wraparound mahogany deck and an open floorplan on the first floor with bedrooms on the second level. The ground-level basement contains a two-car garage, storage space, and a full bathroom, perfect for changing before and after visiting the beach and making use of one of the home’s two outdoor showers. The home’s new buyers will stay cool with central air conditioning and new energy-efficient Anderson windows throughout.
All data and photos are courtesy of Zillow and OneKey MLS.
